tags
acetic anhydridevaluminium chloridephosphorus trioxidezinc chloridepropiothenoneHClacetylmineralaluminium acetateanhydridephosphorus pentoxideaceticpentoxidealuminiumvaluminiumpropionicdichloromethane

video tutorial Acetic anhydride from phosphorus pentoxide and acetic acid

  • Goal: test if acetic anhydride can be made from acetic acid and phosphorus pentoxide (P2O5).
  • Experiment 1: P2O5 with glacial acetic acid; reaction caused rapid heating but was uncontrolled and yielded no useful product.
  • Experiment 2: propionic acid with P2O5; slower reaction, temperature rose, suggesting activity but unclear if anhydride formed.
  • Experiment 3: 80 mL dry dichloromethane with P2O5 and slowly added acetic acid; formed a sticky mass, mild reflux, then distillation yielded only about 10 mL acetic acid; contents carbonized; deemed a failure.
  • Experiment 4: P2O5 and valuminium chloride in mineral oil; added acetic acid gradually; observed HCl fumes and no distillate; failure.
  • Context: prior work suggested propiothenone formation from propionic acid in benzene with valuminium chloride and P2O5; attempts to isolate acetyl chloride produced HCl but no distillate; aluminum acetate may be active.
  • Conclusion: acetic anhydride from acetic acid with P2O5 is not supported by these experiments; acetyl chloride could not be isolated under these conditions; the mystery remains and the claim is deemed myth-busted.

more